Why Good Books Deserve More Good Reviews

More people should review the books they read.

I’ve recently discovered I really enjoy writing book reviews. But not for the reasons you might think.

Yes, it means I get to read more books — and think more critically about them. It ensures that I don’t just rush through a book for the sake of getting through it, put it on a shelf, and dive right into the next one.

But falling in love with writing reviews was something so unexpected that I found myself taking a step back to ask myself why. Why is looking critically at another person’s piece of art so important? And why is it so … rewarding?

It’s not about views or money or anything like that. It’s not even really about what I get out of it … but what the authors of the things I’m reviewing might.

Especially on the internet, people are much more inclined to give negative reviews of things they did not enjoy. They’re much less likely to provide positive feedback for things they loved.

Perhaps book reviews don’t always follow this rule — Goodreads has a way of, for example, prompting you to rate and review things you liked whether you want to or not.

But people “hate review” books on Amazon the way they might any other product. Because they’re unhappy and they want other people — preferably the author — to know it.

When was the last time you gave a good book a good review? Not necessarily a book that changed your life. Just a decent book you’re glad you picked up and read. One you might even consider passing along to a friend or coworker.

You might not even consider reviewing it after you close that back cover. It was good. You’re done reading it. You can move on.

But many if not most authors occasionally peek at reviews. Don’t they? Maybe not always the bad ones. But ALL OF US want to feel good on a not-so-good day. And when you see a four or five-star review on something you made, don’t you want to know what that person liked — even what they might not have liked so much — about it?

You know you do. Don’t lie. :)

If an author has done a good job, they should know about it. It’s nice to be reminded, as a writer, that your work is appreciated. If you’re a writer, you know this. Don’t skip giving a book a review because you can’t think of any criticisms or only feel the need to review books you didn’t think were good.

Tell a writer you had a good time. You never know — it could make their day. Or save their career. Maybe.

Meg is the creator of Novelty Revisions, dedicated to helping writers put their ideas into words. She is a staff writer with The Cheat Sheet, a freelance editor and writer, and a 10-time NaNoWriMo winner. Follow Meg on Twitter for tweets about writing, food and nerdy things.

Help Novelty Revisions become a more valuable resource for aspiring writers.  Join us on Patreon.

5 thoughts on “Why Good Books Deserve More Good Reviews

  1. The smaller the readership, the more likely I am to write a teaser-style review. Authors with hundreds of thousands of readers (who I adore), I’m more likely to just give my stars and move on.

  2. Thanks for the great reminder! I’ve been working on making it a habit to leave reviews for books I’ve enjoyed- especially for the indie authors who it might help out more :) It’s harder when I don’t enjoy the book so much- I tend to pass those ones by…

    1. It’s definitely hard to review something when you can’t pinpoint exactly why you didn’t like it. Every once in a while I’ll read something and just not enjoy it for no particular reason… but that’s why I always say that when you write, you can’t “please” everyone. Not everyone will resonate with everything you write even if there isn’t a particular reason why.

      1. Agreed! And some of the reasons are just personal preference- “Ugh, that character reminds me of so-and-so who’s driving me crazy!” It’s tricky to review fairly when you know the trouble isn’t with the text, just with the way you’re relating to it :)

Compose your words of wisdom

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s